Articles on: Indexation
This article is also available in:

Understand the triennial rent review and indexation

Understand the triennial rent review and indexation


Understand the triennial rent review and indexation


🎯 GOAL: tell apart the mechanisms that change a commercial rent during the lease (indexation clause, statutory triennial rent review, sliding-scale clause), know the rules that govern them, and know how each one is set up in Leasup.




πŸ‘‰ Where

Lease page β€Ί Finance β€Ί Fixed rents & charges β€Ί rent card β€Ί Consult β€Ί Rent review mechanism

πŸ‘€ Who

Legal teams, property managers and real estate managers; every profile can read the set-up.

βœ… Prerequisites

The lease, its amendments and renewal deeds.

⏱️ In practice

When analysing the lease; then as each three-year deadline approaches.


In this article


πŸ‡«πŸ‡· This article applies to leases governed by French law. If your contracts fall under another country's law, the applicable rules differ.



1- Three mechanisms not to mix up



Indexation clause

Statutory triennial rent review

Origin

A clause of the lease

The statutory rules for commercial leases (articles L145-37 and L145-38 of the French Commercial Code)

Trigger

Automatic, on the dates set by the lease

At the request of one party

Frequency

The one set by the lease: every year, every three years…

At the earliest three years after the tenant takes possession or after the rent was last set

Index

The one in the lease

ILC or ILAT

Calculation

The formula in the clause

Capped at the variation of the index, with exceptions

Effect

On the planned date

From the request, without retroactive effect


The sliding-scale clause is the indexation clause seen from the angle of its effect: once it has made the rent vary by more than a quarter, it opens a right to a review (section 4).


⚠️ A rent that changes every three years is not necessarily reviewed: it may be a triennial indexation provided for in the lease. Always identify the mechanism before setting it up.


2- The indexation clause


  • The index. It must be directly related to the subject of the contract or to the activity of one of the parties (article L112-2 of the French Monetary and Financial Code). In commercial leases, the ILC (commercial and craft activities) or the ILAT (office and service activities) is used. The ICC is still found in older leases.
  • The variation period. The index variation period cannot be longer than the time between two revisions (article L112-1 of the French Monetary and Financial Code). The clause that creates this distortion is deemed unwritten.
  • The wording of the clause. It sets the starting index, the comparison index and the indexation date. If it is incomplete, look in the amendments and renewal deeds before choosing.


3- The statutory triennial rent review


  • When. The request can be made at least three years after the date on which the tenant took possession or after the start of the renewed lease; then at least three years after the date on which the revised rent applied (article L145-38 of the French Commercial Code).
  • How much. The increase or decrease of the revised rent cannot exceed the variation of the ILC or the ILAT since the rent was last set, unless a material change in the local commercial factors has led to a variation of more than 10% in the rental value. In that case, the increase is limited, for one year, to 10% of the rent paid the previous year (article L145-38).
  • From when. The revised rent applies from the date of the request: the review has no retroactive effect.


πŸ’‘ TIP: as each three-year deadline approaches, compare the current rent with the variation of the index since the rent was last set. If the index has fallen, the tenant may have an interest in requesting a downward review.


4- The sliding-scale clause


When the lease contains an indexation clause, a review can be requested whenever, through the operation of this clause, the rent has increased or decreased by more than a quarter compared with the price previously set by contract or by court decision. The judge then adapts the operation of the clause to the rental value on the day of the request (article L145-39 of the French Commercial Code).


5- The risky clauses


  • The "upward only" clause. A clause that rules out any decrease in the indexation distorts the normal operation of the index. The Cour de cassation (French Supreme Court) first deemed it unwritten in its entirety (Cour de cassation, 3rd civil chamber, 14 January 2016, no. 14-24.681). It now limits the sanction to the stipulation that prohibits the decrease alone: the rest of the clause continues to apply (Cour de cassation, 3rd civil chamber, 30 June 2021, no. 19-23.038; 12 January 2022, no. 21-11.169).
  • The period distortion. See section 2: Leasup corrects it by default.


6- In Leasup


Mechanism

Set-up

Indexation clause

A recurring indexation: see Index a rent or a charge.

Framed indexation (freeze, cap, floor, weighting)

The Advanced options: see Limit the indexation: freeze, cap, floor, weighting.

Change by a fixed % or an amount

A variation: see Change a cost with a variation.

Period distortion (L112-1)

Corrected by default; the Evolution panel shows an orange triangle art. L112-1 on the revision concerned.

Triennial review obtained

An indexation with the Unique frequency, on the effective date of the review, with the indices used. Enter it once the review has taken place and its details are known.

Review under negotiation

An alert on the deadlines of the procedure, until agreement is reached.


7- Case study: triennial indexation or triennial review?


The MERCATOSUD lease, effective from 1 January 2008, provides that "the rent will be indexed every three years on the ICC". The rent rises from €829,650 to €877,058.57 excl. VAT on 1 January 2011.


Question

Answer

Which mechanism?

A contractual triennial indexation: it applies on its own, without a request.

In Leasup?

A Recurring, Triennial indexation on the ICC.

Can the tenant also request a statutory triennial rent review?

Yes, under the conditions of article L145-38, if there is an interest in doing so. A review obtained is added as a Unique indexation, with the indices used.

Does the variation exceed a quarter?

The current rent (€1,206,027.80) exceeds the rent set in the lease by more than 25%: article L145-39 may apply, to be assessed with your lawyer.


This article is for educational purposes. It is not a legal analysis: the exact terms depend on your lease, its amendments and, if needed, advice from your lawyer.



Going further

Updated on: 20/11/2026

Was this article helpful?

Share your feedback

Cancel

Thank you!